Catholicism as the enemy of modernity: a main thrust in historiography?
Are you already subscribed?
Login to check
whether this content is already included on your personal or institutional subscription.
Abstract
Historians and sociologists of religions have analyzed and understood the links between Christianism, and more particulary Catholicism, and modernity according to three main paradigms. The first one, that I will call conflictual confrontation, argues that modernity is a process that is external to christianism; this interpretational framework identifies antagonistic principles between modernity and Catholicism and focuses on a series of crises. In a second, adaptative paradigm, christianism moves on to an aggiornamento and accepts the main characteristics of modernity, after a long period of resistance. This is visible in its relationship not only to politics and culture, but also internally. A third, homothetic paradigm posits that modernity was not born outside of Christianism, but rather, inside it and resulting from it. This is the paradigm of a modernity intrinsic to christianism. Controversies around post-modernity and the end of religion outline a new configuration that goes beyond these three paradigms.
Keywords
- Modernity
- Secularization
- Integrism