Lucia Donsì Claudia Toscano Antonella Panico

Lying in the Name of the Collective Good: A Study on Developmental "Blue Lies"

Are you already subscribed?
Login to check whether this content is already included on your personal or institutional subscription.

Abstract

The present study investigated the understanding and evaluation, at a developmental age, of the "blue lie", i.e. lying to benefit one's own collectivity. 150 subjects of both sexes, divided into three groups (M a. 8,5; 11,7 and 20,4) were asked to evaluate the statements of the main character of each of 4 short stories involving a conflict between the benefit for the self vs. the collectivity, requiring them to choose between the two. There was a variation both in the type of statement (a lie or a truth) and the beneficiary (the self or the collectivity). The results show that there was a significant age-related difference in both identifying the beneficiary of the main character's statement and in categorizing the answers as a lie or as a truth, although not in the sense of a linear improvement. Moreover they signalled that the positive evaluation of lying to benefit the collective increased with age. There was a significant difference between the children on the one hand and the pre-adolescents and young adults on the other. This indicated a complex influence as regards the sociocultural context, and a need for further investigation.

Keywords

  • Lie
  • Collectivism
  • Cultural Influence
  • Social Cognition

Preview

Article first page

What do you think about the recent suggestion?

Trova nel catalogo di Worldcat